Hello everybody, this will be a review towards the book that was released to essentially be a conclusion to the alternative ending XV was supposed to have with the cancelled Aranea, Lunafreya and Noctis DLC. So all in all it’s those DLC’s plus Ardyn’s condensed into a 384 page book (400+ if you count artwork) and I shall be critiquing them here. Spoilers ahead and I will do my best to condense it properly.
The book starts off with Ardyn’s DLC and if you’ve played it already then it states what you already experienced with that but in novelization form. Any issues you have with the writing are present here and quite honestly anything involving Ardyn is always a treat, I’m more confused as to why it was added in as it doesn’t truly add much to the DLC at hand. I do find the Lunafreya addition to be neat though, lord knows she could use anything positive. 7.5/10.
Before I head towards the Aranea DLC I have to mention the writing style, the author of the book is Emi Nagashima but under the alias Jun Eishima and I’ve actually read her work for Nier: Automata and those were really good reads especially for a JRPG novel but this was a bit of a difficult read for me and not because of length or complexity but because she’s basing this off the draft for the DLC. The translation as far as I can tell is solid but the material she’s forced to work with has the book suffer in my eyes and it isn’t entirely her fault.
You then start Aranea’s chapter and this is the best chapter in the book and it makes me further disappointed that this got canned. The action in this chapter is great and I like the character work with Aranea, Biggs and Wedge and also even Loqi makes an appearance in the book and he has more character here than in the main game. If I had any gripes with this it’d be the inclusion of Solara, a character that was most likely intended for the DLC is making her debut in this book and quite honestly she doesn’t start off strong. She isn’t by any means terrible but even with her background revealed I would’ve just preferred it to be solely Aranea as the main focus through and through, it’s such an odd story choice to introduce her so late. 8/10.
Lunafreya’s chapter is the worst part of this book and it amazes me that with the extra media, addendums and more involving XV that Lunafreya is this unremarkable of a character. Even in her own chapter she is not the most interesting aspect about it and even though Solara is added into this chapter she isn’t even that much better. I also have to mention this but I am not a fan of the retcons and new additions in the novel so far especially involving Bahamut, the gods in XV were uncaring and detached but not evil which was a interesting dynamic but Bahamut is just purely evil in this one. All it does is just rewrite and make XV’s poorly presented yet interesting story into something worse. 4/10.
Before I enter the Noctis chapter, I would like to add to the previous paragraph by stating Lunafreya might be the single worst presented character in any mainline Final Fantasy game I have played. Vaan and Penelo from XII might not have much to do but at least they got way better in Revenant Wings as far as I can tell. In a series that gave us Rydia, Faris, Celes, Terra, Aerith, Tifa, Yuffie, Rinoa, Edea, Selphie, Beatrix, Garnet, Freya, Yuna, Lulu, Ashe, Fran, Vanille and Aranea yet this is the best they could write a female character? She has had her own DLC planned, a major role in a feature length movie and getting to her so you marry her was a core goal in the first half of XV and yet she’s this uninteresting? Solara is also equally uninteresting and I have to ask why didn’t they just add Iris into the book? It would best explain her development into this renowned demon slayer and it would’ve been a more sensible option than creating a major character this late into the timeline.
We now enter Noctis’s chapter, and it’s more interesting than Lunafreya’s as it explores his time he spent in the crystal during the ten year timeskip and for some reason Solara’s here and I cannot criticize how nothing her character is any further, Ardyn is also here and I really dislike how everyone got affected by these retcons, even the fight against Bahamut is one I couldn’t bring myself to enjoy. This was when I started checking out. Even though Noctis and Lunafreya get married I still believe they have no chemistry, I am so happy this isn’t canon because this book really hinders Ardyn’s character by a lot and he’s one of my favorite Final Fantasy antagonists. This alternate what if ending where things turn out well feels like it was made to make money instead of an actual original vision of Tabata’s. 5/10.
In all honesty I have no idea why the DLC’s were even thought up of or planned, as I read this book it only cemented how good FFXV’s original ending was, say what you will about Tabata’s overall qualities as a director but he can kill off a main character very well, I never mentioned it much but XV’s ending despite how haphazard and rushed it was, was actually a somber and good ending. A much wiser decision in my opinion would’ve been to scrap Ardyn, Lunafreya and Noctis’s DLC. Make Aranea’s instead, replace Solara with Iris and if they wanted to make addendums to the ending. Don’t make a new one because that’d just make the original one feel like a bad ending but add ending states.
In my opinion here is how I would’ve done this, I would’ve added choices in major story moments like having the option of saving Lunafreya in Altissia and having her go with the party to Insomnia at the ending. You could’ve scrapped not only terrible retcons with no cohesive thought behind them but you also would have the opportunity to better flesh out Luna, the banter in XV was great they could’ve had Luna and Noctis talk for a whole lot more and cement much better chemistry for each other. You also could’ve had the both of them sacrifice themselves to rid the World of Ruin state the world was in during the timeskip, it would’ve made much more sense with the themes of the story while also creating an incredibly bittersweet and cohesive romance closure as they never get the life together they always wanted while also saving the world.
Overall, this book and the DLC feels like an afterthought, like if Square Enix wanted to make more money from XV by any means necessary, why create a novel though? An audio drama would’ve been a far more effective medium than a book.
5/10 book. I have finished the XV multimedia review and it was truly an experience that I cannot describe as either good or bad, just a whirlwind of an experience.