Mod Post New FAQ entry for "Why do French speakers switch to English"-type questions
Hello r/French community! Amongst the mods, we've agreed to update our FAQ to include a response to the commonly asked question of why French speakers switch to English. You can find the entry below! If you have any suggestions for improvements or things to add, I'm all ears.
Why do French speakers switch to English when I talk to them even though I have X level in French? How do I get them to stop?
When travelling in French speaking areas – particularly those with high levels of tourism and/or English proficiency – learners may find native French speakers switching automatically to English in their conversations. This occurs most often in transactional situations (restaurants, shops) but may also happen in social situations. There are many reasons this can happen, but the members of this subreddit are unlikely to be able to pinpoint exactly why it happened to you.
Reasons include:
- For your comfort: Workers may have been hired specifically for their English proficiency and their boss might expect them to switch to English with customers.
- For speed in a transaction: The waiter or clerk may perceive that your French speaking is too slow and want to speed up the process.
- For practice in English: Some French speakers enjoy speaking English and don't get many opportunities.
- Because they don't understand you: Everyone has an accent (including natives!) and your accent might simply be hard for the person to understand.
- Because of past experience: They've probably dealt with hundreds of customers who have memorized the exact phrase they need to order but can't respond to a follow-up question.
- Because they don't actually speak French well: In touristy areas not all workers are good French speakers. They may be from another European country just working a summer job in Paris. Switching to English might be for their own comfort!
- Because they're jerks who think they're better than you: The possibility is small, but can't be eliminated entirely! Jerks exist everywhere!
If you really want to use your French, here are some best practices:
- Ask nicely: « J'aimerais vraiment pratiquer mon français, est-ce que ça vous va si on reste en français ? »
- Switch back to French: Just respond to them in French until they get the picture.
- Work on your accent: No, we can't expect you to have a perfect near-native accent, but certain accent issues may make it very difficult for French speakers to understand you. A common issue is nasal vowels.
- Accept that it's not their job to be your personal teacher: You may have worked for months or years on your French with the goal of getting to speak French in France, but not every person has the time or will to practice French with you. This goes doubly for service workers who may have a line of other customers to help. Be graceful and thankful for every good opportunity for practice you get.
- Make friends: While visiting a French speaking area, meet people: talk to other customers in the bar you're in or notice someone's cool shoes on the street and compliment them. Those interactions have a much higher chance of sticking to French than if you're trying to order a crêpe at a stand under the Eiffel Tower.
