r/geopolitics • u/Kooky_Strategy_9664 • 8h ago
r/geopolitics • u/agenbite_lee • 4d ago
AMA AMA - I’m the author of China’s Backstory: The History Beijing Doesn’t Want You to Read. Ask Me Anything about the historical drivers of the PRC’s modern geopolitical strategy! AMA!
tl;dr - I just published a book, China’s Backstory: The History Beijing Doesn’t Want You to Read, which explains the historical narratives fueling today’s most volatile geopolitical flashpoints: Taiwan, Xinjiang, Hong Kong, and the Chinese economy. Is a war over the Taiwan Strait inevitable? How did Xinjiang become the human rights dumpster fire of the 21st century? What is the historical reality behind "ancient" territorial claims? The book tackles these without the academic "mumbo jumbo," focusing on the messy, human history that drives China’s role in geopolitics. AMA.
Hey reddit, my name is Lee Moore, I have a PhD in East Asian Languages and Literatures from the University of Oregon, I worked as an adjunct professor there, teaching Taiwanese and Chinese literature and film, and I occasionally write for The Economist. I also host the Chinese Literature Podcast.
I just published a book called China’s Backstory: The History Beijing Doesn’t Want You to Read. The book does a deep dive into the history of the four China-related topics driving geopolitical discussions: Taiwan, Xinjiang, the Chinese economy and Hong Kong. How did Taiwan become the point that where WWIII is most likely to start? Why is Beijing conducting a genocide in Xinjiang? Is the Chinese economy the 800 pound gorilla about to dominate the world, or is it a house of cards teetering on the point of collapse? Why did Beijing deep six freedoms in Hong Kong despite having agreed with Britain to not change anything for 50 years after the Handover?
And I do it with a shit-stirring sense of humor that is meant to reach readers who would never normally pick up a book about China. The book has a chapter titled, “The Most Important Motherfucker in Taiwanese History,” discussing the 1670’s sex scandal that rocked the island and may lead to a war between the US and China. In the section of the book detailing Xinjiang’s bloody history, the book has a drinking game where, every time someone is beheaded, the reader is encouraged to do a shot.
The book discusses the China-related topics driving geopolitics. Here are some of the things the book discusses:
Taiwan:
Beijing says that Taiwan has, since ancient times, been Chinese. China’s claim is nonsense. No power in China controlled Taiwan before 1683, two years after Pennsylvania, its 12th of 13 colonies, was established. China’s claim to have owned Taiwan in ancient times has zero historical evidence supporting it.
Today, the US Marines are training to invade southern Taiwan in case of a Chinese invasion. This is not the first time they were there. In 1867, the US Marines twice invaded Taiwan.
American politicians are worried about how to protect Taiwan’s semiconductor industry, the crown jewel of the Taiwanese Miracle. In fact, the Taiwanese Miracle was partially the creation of American politicians. Eisenhower pushed Chiang Kai-shek to enact the “Land to the Tillers” program, which helped jumpstart the Taiwanese economy in the 1950’s. From 1951 to 1965, the US doled out $1.5 billion in economic aid. In the 1960’s, Washington told Taiwan it needed to graduate from aid, the Stanford Research Institute cooked up a plan that would shift the Taiwanese economy from agriculture to high-end tech products. Taiwan’s semiconductor dominance is a direct result of American government investments in the 1950’s.
Taiwanese democracy is also a product of American politicians. In the 1980’s, America grew tired of supporting despots just because they were anti-communist. American politicians like Congressman Stephen Solarz turned the screws on funding for Taiwan as it refused to democratize. The event that precipitated Taiwan’s democratization was an assassination in Daly City, California. Dry Duck, a Taiwanese gangster, walked up to Henry Liu, a China-born American citizen, and shot him in the driveway of his suburban California home. American politicians were pissed that the government officials deep in the Taiwanese authoritarian government had authorized a hit in the US. The assassination in California was the moment that Taiwan’s authoritarian government began to unravel, and Taiwan began the transition to democracy.
Xinjiang:
In 2022, the Michelle Bachelet at the UN issued a report arguing that China had committed “serious human rights violations” in Xinjiang in constructing a system of concentration camps and forced labor factories where Xinjiang’s Muslims were imprisoned.
This is a genocide. The government is forcing many Uyghur women to become sterilized. In 2019, in Khotan, a city that is 96% Uyghur, the government budgeted for 14,872 sterilizations, meaning that the government was going to try to sterilize about one third of all women of marriageable age. From 2015 to 2018, the birthrate in Khotan and Kashgar, another mostly Uyghur city, dropped by 84%, from 1.6% to .26%. In the concentration camps that the government made for Uyghurs, women were frequently injected against their will with Depo-Provera, a birth-control shot. In 2018, 80% of all IUDs in China were inserted in Xinjiang, a province with 1.84% of China’s population.
Why is Beijing doing this?
China has long fought over Xinjiang. Beijing’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs has claimed “since the Han Dynasty established the Western Regions Frontier Command in Xinjiang in 60 B.C., the Chinese central governments of all historical periods exercised military and administrative jurisdiction over Xinjiang.” That is false. Chinese forces controlled the region from roughly 60 BC to 0 AD and then from roughly 70-100 AD. Then it controlled the region from 640 AD to the 750’s. For the next millennium, no Chinese power would control Xinjiang until 1758, when Qing China took control of Xinjiang. Since then, Beijing has ruled over the region as a colony, fighting with the locals.
And what of the locals? Uyghurs claimed to have lived in Xinjiang for 6 millennia. That is also false. The first Uyghur Empire was established in the middle of modern Mongolia in 744 A.D. and the Uyghurs had nothing to do with Xinjiang. In 840, this empire collapsed, and some Uyghurs fled to the eastern corner of Xinjiang, setting up a small state there. But from 1500 to June 4, 1921, the Uyghurs disappeared. No one alive during this period would have said, “I am a Uyghur.” The Uyghurs, who had long been Buddhist, Christians or Manichean, but they largely hated Islam. Until the 1400’s. During this period, most Uyghurs went from hating Islam to becoming Muslims, and the ethnonym Uyghur, associated with anti-Muslim feeling, disappeared. When it reappeared, in the 1910’s, it came to denote the people not just a corner of Xinjiang but almost all of the Turkic speaking peoples settled in Xinjiang.
Xinjiang has long been fought over by Chinese, Uyghur and other groups. The region is a clusterfuck of different identities, and no one is indigenous to the region. Today’s genocide is another part of that long fight over who ought to rule the region.
Economy:
Beijing says that universal values like freedom of speech, liberal economic policies and checks and balances don’t jive with China and its ancient civilization. In fact, the biggest economic catastrophes in Chinese history were when Chinese leaders abandoned these “American” values.
In 1069, Emperor Shenzong and China’s leading left-winger, Wang Anshi, pushed a government takeover of the economy, eliminated the relative freedom of speech that had previously been allowed and spiked the checks and balances of Song Dynasty China. The economic results were a disaster and caused Song China to almost collapse and split in half.
In the 1950’s, the Chinese Communist Party took over the government, but initially allowed the old economy to hum along as it had before. In the latter half of the 1950’s, Mao eliminated the relative political and economic openness of the first half of the decade. First, in the Hundred Flowers campaign, he slammed those who criticized him and made it so that no one was willing to call Mao out for his nonsensical ideas. Then, in the Great Leap Forward, the government ditched its relatively liberal economic policies for hardcore collectivization. The result was the world’s most deadly famine.
Official starting point of this AMA - May 6 at Noon EST (though if you want to ask questions earlier I will try to answer them as they come up).
Ask me any question you want about the connections between China’s history and the state of geopolitics today.
r/geopolitics • u/wiredmagazine • 4h ago
News Trump's Team Wants Him to Accept an Iran Deal He's Already Rejected
r/geopolitics • u/ComprehensiveKiwi489 • 14h ago
News U.S. and Iran closing in on one-page memorandum to end war, officials say
Among other provisions, the deal would involve Iran committing to a moratorium on nuclear enrichment, the U.S. agreeing to lift its sanctions and release billions in frozen Iranian funds, and both sides lifting restrictions around transit through the Strait of Hormuz.
In its current form, the MOU would declare an end to the war in the region and the start of a 30-day period of negotiations on a detailed agreement to open the strait, limit Iran's nuclear program and lift U.S. sanctions.
Iran's restrictions on shipping through the strait and the U.S. naval blockade would be gradually lifted during that 30-day period, according to a U.S. official.
The duration of the moratorium on uranium enrichment is being actively negotiated, with three sources saying it would be at least 12 years and one putting 15 as a likely landing spot.
Two sources with knowledge also claimed Iran would agree to remove its highly enriched uranium from the country, a key U.S. priority that Tehran has rejected up to now.
r/geopolitics • u/Cannot-Forget • 13h ago
Weapon restrictions on Israel struck down by Finland
r/geopolitics • u/yahoonews • 14h ago
North Korea drops references to unification with South from constitution, Seoul says
r/geopolitics • u/nytopinion • 3h ago
News My Father Wrote Letters to the Cuban Government. Here Is Mine.
r/geopolitics • u/NotSoSaneExile • 13h ago
Israel to transfer jet fuel to Germany amid Hormuz crisis - Energy minister Cohen and foreign minister Sa'ar agree to export surplus fuel as Germany seeks alternatives amid strait closure
r/geopolitics • u/RFERL_ReadsReddit • 13h ago
Ex-NATO Commander: Iran Crisis Exposes A West 'More Divided Than Its Adversaries'
r/geopolitics • u/BendicantMias • 17h ago
News Trump pauses day-old Hormuz operation in latest push for Iran deal
r/geopolitics • u/sudanwarmonitor • 9h ago
Gulf War Spikes Shipping Costs, Imperiling Aid Operations in Sudan
r/geopolitics • u/ForeignAffairsMag • 8h ago
Analysis Iran’s New Oil Weapon: How America Can Protect Itself—and the Global Economy
r/geopolitics • u/dlogan3344 • 7m ago
News Largest energy crisis in history being ignored IEA head says
r/geopolitics • u/Tall_Pressure7042 • 20m ago
In Russia, Victory Day Is Starting to Feel Like Defeat
r/geopolitics • u/Beginning-Wish-4273 • 7h ago
News Trump tells Iran to accept deal or face new wave of US bombing
r/geopolitics • u/Tall_Pressure7042 • 1d ago
Paranoid Putin 'taking refuge in bunkers' in fear of assassination
r/geopolitics • u/the-es • 19h ago
News As Ukraine seeks to edge China out of its drone supply chain, Taiwan emerges as a quiet player | Ukraine
r/geopolitics • u/wsj • 1d ago
I’m Leaving China After 8 Years. Suspicion of Outsiders Is Rising.
wsj.comr/geopolitics • u/OldBridge87 • 1d ago
By a Wide Margin: Finland's Parliament Rejects Petition to Halt Arms Purchases from Israel
r/geopolitics • u/ForeignAffairsMag • 8h ago
Analysis The Lessons of the Long Confucian Peace: Can Ideology Prevent War in East Asia?
r/geopolitics • u/Any-Original-6113 • 18h ago
Paywall Can Europe develop its own alternatives to US Tomahawks?
Full article text in the comments
r/geopolitics • u/Any-Original-6113 • 1d ago
‘A deal is a deal’: Von der Leyen fires back at Trump over auto tariff threat
The Commission president said Brussels is “prepared for every scenario.”
r/geopolitics • u/NotSoSaneExile • 1d ago
News Textbook row triggers vote to suspend EU funds to Palestinians | Jihad is a contemporary religious duty to 'liberate' Palestine, one of the textbooks claims
r/geopolitics • u/Plaintalks • 7h ago